When choosing the right roofing material for your home, the decision between asphalt and metal shingles is crucial, especially in a city like Pittsburgh with its varied weather patterns. Both types of shingles offer unique benefits and challenges, making them popular choices among homeowners. Asphalt shingles are known for their cost-effectiveness and versatility, while metal shingles boast remarkable durability and longevity. Understanding the pros and cons of each in the context of Pittsburgh’s climate, which includes harsh winters and humid summers, is essential for making an informed decision that ensures both the safety and aesthetic appeal of your home.


Asphalt Shingles:

Pittsburgh Roof Ventilation

The average lifespan of asphalt shingles, like the Owens Corning products installed by Craig Gouker Roofing, is about 50 years. This durability can vary based on factors like installation quality, maintenance, and Pittsburgh’s weather, which includes harsh winters and humid summers.

Regular maintenance can significantly extend their lifespan. These shingles are designed to resist common weather damages, making them a reliable choice for the local climate. Additionally, asphalt shingles are more affordable compared to metal options, offering a cost-effective solution for homeowners seeking quality roofing without a hefty price tag.


Metal Roof

Metal Shingles:

Metal shingles, come with their own set of challenges. They require less maintenance and are highly durable against extreme weather. However, it’s important to note that not all metal roofs are created equal.


The less expensive options, which might be comparable in price to higher-end asphalt shingles, can have issues like leaking due to the expansion and contraction of screws in varying weather conditions. This is a significant consideration, especially in a climate like Pittsburgh’s.


While metal roofs can last longer, the higher-quality ones that offer this extended durability can be significantly more expensive, often costing double that of a shingle roof. This steep initial investment is a major consideration for homeowners. The upfront cost can be prohibitive, especially when compared to the more affordable and reliable asphalt shingle options like those offered by Craig Gouker Roofing.

Compare & Contrast:

  • Weather Suitability in Pittsburgh: Asphalt shingles, like those from Owens Corning, are specifically designed to handle the region’s snowy winters and humid summers, offering resilience against common weather damages. Metal roofs, while durable, can face issues in extreme temperature fluctuations, impacting their longevity.

  • Aesthetic and Design Options: Asphalt shingles offer a wide range of styles and colors, fitting various architectural designs. Metal roofs, though more limited in aesthetic variety, provide a modern and sleek look that can complement contemporary home styles.

  • Return on Investment: Asphalt shingles provide a more immediate return on investment due to their lower upfront cost and durability. Metal roofs, despite their potential for long-term savings, require a significantly higher initial investment, which might not be as feasible for all homeowners.


In conclusion, for homeowners in Pittsburgh considering a roof replacement, opting for Owens Corning shingle roofing installed by Craig Gouker Roofing offers a balanced blend of affordability, style, and durability, tailored to the local climate.


While metal roofs have their merits, their high initial cost and potential issues in varying weather conditions make them less ideal.

Trust in our expertise and commitment to quality, ensuring your investment in an Owens Corning shingle roof provides both immediate and long-term value for your home.